Skip to content 
Choosing the right window material can dramatically impact your home’s energy efficiency, maintenance costs, and long-term value. Two popular options dominate today’s market: Andersen’s proprietary Fibrex composite and traditional vinyl (PVC) windows. Both offer low-maintenance solutions, but they differ significantly in durability, performance, and price. This guide breaks down the key differences to help homeowners make an informed decision.
What is Fibrex Material?
Fibrex is Andersen’s patented composite material that combines 40% reclaimed wood fiber (mostly from their own manufacturing processes) with 60% thermoplastic polymer by weight. Originally developed in 1958 and patented in 1991, Fibrex was created to reduce manufacturing waste by repurposing sawdust from Andersen’s wood window production.
The composite material addresses a key weakness of exposed wood: rot. Because each wood fiber is surrounded and sealed with PVC, Fibrex resists decay, fungal growth, and moisture damage far better than pure wood. The material can be extruded or injection-molded, allowing for complex shapes and slimmer frame profiles that maximize glass area and natural light.
Andersen uses Fibrex across its premium window lines, including the 100 Series, A-Series, and Renewal by Andersen replacement windows. The company has largely moved away from pure vinyl products in recent years, selling off its vinyl-focused brands like Silverline and American Craftsman in 2018.
What Are Vinyl Windows?
Vinyl windows are made entirely from polyvinyl chloride (PVC), specifically unplasticized PVC (uPVC), which provides superior durability. First popularized in the 1960s as a low-maintenance alternative to aluminum and wood, vinyl promised windows that never needed scraping or painting.
Vinyl remains the most popular window material today due to its affordability, energy efficiency, and minimal maintenance requirements. Quality vinyl windows typically last 20-40 years depending on manufacturing quality, installation, and climate conditions. Premium vinyl windows with proper installation can exceed 30 years of service life.
Key Differences Between Fibrex and Vinyl Windows
Strength and Durability
Fibrex boasts twice the compressive strength of vinyl. This superior strength allows manufacturers to create slimmer window frames without sacrificing structural integrity, resulting in larger glass areas and more natural light. The wood fiber content helps Fibrex maintain dimensional stability across extreme temperature ranges.
Vinyl windows are highly durable and resist moisture, rot, and insect damage better than wood or aluminum. However, vinyl can become brittle over time with prolonged UV exposure, and lower-quality vinyl may warp or sag in extreme heat. Quality vinyl windows typically last 30-40 years with minimal maintenance.
Thermal Performance and Energy Efficiency
Both materials offer excellent insulating properties. Andersen’s internal documentation states that Fibrex’s insulating properties are comparable to pine or vinyl, with a thermal conductivity rating of approximately 0.15. This performs significantly better than aluminum (which rates above 0.60) but is roughly equivalent to vinyl’s insulation value.
Fibrex blocks thermal transfer nearly 700 times better than aluminum, helping reduce heating and cooling costs. Composite windows generally provide superior air infiltration performance compared to vinyl, creating tighter seals that prevent drafts. However, high-quality vinyl windows with fusion-welded frames can match or exceed composite performance in energy efficiency testing.
Heat Resistance and Thermal Expansion
Fibrex demonstrates superior heat distortion resistance with a threshold of 173°F compared to vinyl’s 163°F. While this 10-degree advantage exists, both materials remain below the critical distortion starting point of 180°F under normal conditions.
Thermal expansion represents a more significant difference. Vinyl expands at a rate of 4.0 when exposed to temperature changes, while Fibrex’s wood fiber content reduces its expansion rate to just 1.6. This lower expansion rate means Fibrex maintains tighter seals and experiences less warping over decades of temperature cycling.
Appearance and Color Options
Vinyl windows offer extensive color choices, with many manufacturers providing 10-15 standard colors plus unlimited custom options. Modern vinyl can mimic wood grain textures while maintaining the low-maintenance benefits of plastic.
Fibrex windows typically feature fewer color options but integrate color directly into the material during production rather than applying surface coatings. This manufacturing process creates fade-resistant exteriors that won’t flake, blister, peel, or corrode. The composite material provides a more natural wood-like appearance on interiors.
Cost Considerations
Vinyl windows remain the more affordable option, making them popular for budget-conscious homeowners. Composite Fibrex windows carry higher upfront costs for both materials and installation. However, Fibrex’s extended lifespan (potentially 40+ years versus vinyl’s 20-30 years) can provide better long-term value through reduced replacement frequency.
Premium vinyl windows offer an excellent middle ground, providing many benefits of composite materials at lower price points. The total cost difference depends on window size, quantity, installation complexity, and regional labor rates.
Maintenance Requirements
Both materials require minimal maintenance compared to wood or aluminum windows. Neither needs painting, scraping, or protective coatings. Regular cleaning with mild soap and water keeps both materials looking fresh.
Fibrex’s resistance to rot, decay, and fungal growth gives it a slight maintenance advantage in humid climates or homes with limited sun exposure. Vinyl performs equally well in most environments but may develop brittleness or discoloration after 15-20 years of intense sun exposure.
Environmental Impact
Fibrex offers clear environmental advantages by using 40% reclaimed wood fiber from Andersen’s own manufacturing waste. This recycling process diverts sawdust, adhesives, paint, primer, and anti-fungal agents from landfills and incinerators. Andersen maintains control over its supply chain, reducing transportation impacts.
Some vinyl window manufacturers now incorporate post-consumer recycled plastics into their products, improving vinyl’s environmental profile. However, virgin PVC production remains more resource-intensive than using reclaimed wood fiber. Both materials are recyclable at end-of-life, though actual recycling rates vary by location.
Which Window Material Should You Choose?
Select Fibrex composite windows if you prioritize maximum durability, minimal thermal expansion, superior heat resistance, and environmental sustainability. Fibrex makes sense for homeowners planning long-term ownership (20+ years) who want premium performance and can accommodate higher upfront investment.
Choose vinyl windows if you need cost-effective, energy-efficient windows with proven performance and extensive design options. Vinyl provides excellent value for budget-conscious projects, rental properties, or situations where replacement cycles of 20-30 years are acceptable.
Both materials vastly outperform older aluminum or wood windows in energy efficiency, maintenance requirements, and longevity. The “right” choice depends on your specific budget, climate, home style, and long-term plans.
Upgrade Your Home with Expert Windows
Ready to improve your home’s energy efficiency and curb appeal with new windows? Expert Windows specializes in helping Irish homeowners select and install the perfect window solutions for their needs and budget. Whether you’re considering composite, vinyl, or other modern window materials, our experienced team provides professional guidance and quality installation throughout Ireland.
Contact Expert Windows today for a free consultation and discover how new windows can reduce your energy bills, enhance comfort, and increase your property value.
