Skip to content 
Choosing between Pella and Andersen windows can feel overwhelming, but understanding the key differences will help make your decision easier. Both brands are industry leaders with solid reputations, but they cater to different budgets, material preferences, and installation needs.
Understanding the Brands
Andersen Windows: A Century of Innovation
Andersen Corporation was founded in 1903 by Danish immigrant Hans Andersen in Hudson, Wisconsin. Today, the company operates from Bayport, Minnesota, with over 30 manufacturing facilities across North America. Andersen is organized into three main divisions: Renewal by Andersen (replacement windows with full-service installation), the Home Depot Division, and the Residential and Commercial Pro Division.
Andersen reported approximately $2.5 billion in annual sales, making it one of the largest window manufacturers in North America. The brand has received recognition from J.D. Power for highest customer satisfaction among window and patio door manufacturers.
Pella Corporation: American Craftsmanship
Pella Corporation was founded in 1925 in Pella, Iowa, by Peter Kuyper, who initially created retractable insect screens. The company has since evolved into a major window and door manufacturer with approximately 6,000 employees and $2 billion in annual revenue. Pella maintains partnerships with Lowes Home Improvement through their Design Centers and offers both new construction and replacement windows.
Window Materials and Construction
Andersen’s Proprietary Fibrex Material
Andersen is known for its innovative Fibrex composite material, which combines 40 percent recycled Ponderosa pine wood fibers with 60 percent polyvinyl chloride (PVC). This proprietary blend offers the strength and aesthetic appeal of wood with the low-maintenance benefits of vinyl. While Andersen primarily focuses on Fibrex and wood options, vinyl windows are available through their American Craftsman line at Home Depot.
Pella’s Versatile Material Options
Pella offers greater variety in frame materials, including all-vinyl, fiberglass, and wood options through their Replacement by Pella division. The Impervia series features fiberglass frames, while other series provide vinyl and wood-clad choices. This flexibility allows homeowners to select materials based on budget, maintenance preferences, and aesthetic goals.
Pricing Comparison
Andersen Window Costs
Andersen windows typically range from $400 to $4,000 per window, depending on the series, size, and customization options. The 100 Series offers more affordable options at $400 to $1,500 installed, while premium A-Series and E-Series windows can cost $1,200 to $3,700+ per window installed. Renewal by Andersen’s full-service replacement packages generally start around $1,000 per window and can exceed $1,400 for larger or more complex installations.
Pella Window Costs
Pella windows are generally more affordable, ranging from $400 to $2,000 per window installed. The 250 Series starts at approximately $250 to $850, while premium Reserve Series windows range from $1,300 to $3,000. Homeowners typically report paying between $770 and $1,100 per window for Pella replacement installations.
Cost Verdict
Pella windows are approximately 20 to 30 percent less expensive than comparable Andersen products. Pella’s entry-level pricing aligns with Andersen’s mid-range options, making Pella more accessible for budget-conscious homeowners.
Product Lines and Series
Andersen Window Series
Andersen offers five main product lines with varying price points and features:
-
100 Series: Most affordable, vinyl construction, basic features ($400-$1,500 installed)
-
200 Series: Mid-range option with more customization ($450-$2,000 installed)
-
400 Series: Popular choice with Fibrex frames and extensive options ($500-$3,000 installed)
-
A-Series: High-end customizable windows for architectural projects ($1,200-$3,700+ installed)
-
E-Series: Premium line with extensive wood options ($1,000-$3,200+ installed)
Pella Window Series
Pella provides seven distinct window series to accommodate different needs and budgets:
-
250 Series: Entry-level vinyl windows ($250-$850)
-
Encompass: Budget-friendly replacement option ($200-$900)
-
Lifestyle: Mid-range with more features ($300-$1,500)
-
Impervia: Fiberglass construction for durability ($300-$1,700)
-
Defender: Impact-resistant for storm protection ($700-$1,500)
-
Hurricane Shield: Enhanced storm protection ($700-$1,500)
-
Architect and Reserve: Premium custom options ($1,200-$3,000)
Customer Reviews and Complaints
Pella Customer Feedback
Recent customer reviews indicate mixed experiences with Pella windows. Common complaint categories include product quality issues (approximately 50 percent of complaints), local dealer service problems (45 percent), installation issues (3 percent), and sales practices (2 percent).
BBB complaints from 2023-2024 frequently mention measurement errors, defective products upon delivery, lengthy repair timelines, and inadequate customer service follow-up. Some customers reported waiting months for trim pieces and replacement parts, with ongoing issues after initial installation.
Andersen Customer Feedback
Andersen receives significantly fewer complaints overall compared to Pella. Complaint distribution includes sales practices (40 percent), local dealer issues (30 percent), product quality (15 percent), and installation problems (15 percent).
Renewal by Andersen received recognition from J.D. Power in 2024 for highest customer satisfaction among window and patio door manufacturer brands. However, some customers report concerns about aggressive sales tactics and premium pricing.
Satisfaction Verdict
Andersen demonstrates stronger overall customer satisfaction ratings and receives approximately 90 percent fewer complaints than Pella. When issues arise with Andersen products, they more frequently relate to sales practices rather than product quality.
Energy Efficiency and Performance
Both manufacturers offer energy-efficient window options that meet or exceed Energy Star requirements. Andersen’s Fibrex material provides excellent thermal performance due to its low-expansion characteristics. Pella’s triple-pane and insulated glass options deliver comparable energy savings, particularly in their Lifestyle and Impervia series.
Advanced features like Low-E glass coatings, argon gas fills, and insulated frames are available from both brands to reduce heating and cooling costs. The actual energy performance depends more on proper installation and window configuration than brand selection.
Warranty Coverage
Andersen Warranties
Andersen offers a 20-year limited warranty on glass, a 10-year warranty on components, and a 2-year installation warranty when installed by authorized dealers. Renewal by Andersen provides more comprehensive coverage through their full-service installation packages.
Pella Warranties
Pella provides a limited lifetime warranty on most window components, covering materials and workmanship defects. Specific coverage varies by product series and installation method. Independent installers may offer separate workmanship warranties.
Installation Services
Andersen Installation
Renewal by Andersen provides start-to-finish replacement services through authorized local contractors who measure, manufacture, and install windows. This full-service approach ensures quality control but comes at a premium price. Andersen windows purchased through Home Depot typically require separate contractor arrangements.
Pella Installation
Replacement by Pella operates similarly, offering complete installation packages through certified local dealers who can adjust pricing based on project scope. Pella windows purchased through Lowes may involve either Pella-certified installers or independent contractors.
Which Brand Should You Choose?
Choose Andersen If:
-
Premium quality and material innovation are priorities
-
Budget allows for higher upfront investment ($1,000+ per window)
-
You value Fibrex composite construction
-
Full-service installation with comprehensive warranty appeals to you
-
Customer satisfaction ratings are important
Choose Pella If:
-
Budget is a primary concern (20-30% less than Andersen)
-
You prefer more material choices (vinyl, fiberglass, wood)
-
You want multiple product series at various price points
-
You’re comfortable managing installation details
-
Local dealer relationships are already established
Professional Window Installation in Ireland
Whether you’re considering Pella, Andersen, or exploring other quality window options, proper installation is crucial for performance, energy efficiency, and longevity. Both brands emphasize that even the highest-quality windows will underperform if incorrectly installed.
Looking for expert window installation services in Ireland? Expert Windows specializes in professional window installation, replacement, and repairs for homes and businesses throughout Ireland. Our experienced team ensures proper fitting, weatherproofing, and optimal energy performance for every project. Contact Expert Windows today at expertwindows.ie for a free consultation and discover how quality installation makes all the difference.
Final Thoughts
Both Pella and Andersen deliver quality windows backed by established companies with decades of experience. Andersen leads in customer satisfaction and material innovation, while Pella offers greater affordability and product variety.
Your decision should balance budget constraints, material preferences, installation needs, and long-term maintenance considerations. Focus on proper installation quality regardless of brand choice, as this factor significantly impacts window performance and durability.
